I sit here tonight pondering the question “When is hope a beam of light in the darkness and when it is merely a delusional wish?” Or to rephrase, “Will bunk beds succeed when all else has failed?”
Though I have faced many parenting challenges over the last 9 years, and though I have run across several things I wish I had handled better or differently, I have only had one true parenting failure to date. But it’s a biggie.
My darling Tate, 7, my sweet, funny, smart, sassy, lively, independent, stubborn child does not sleep. Jill laments the fact the two of her boys are picky eaters. I have a picky sleeper. And, like Reid and Mack, the issue isn’t threadcount of the sheets or mattress firmness or the amount of light in the room, it is sleeping. Tate does not like to fall asleep, and she does not stay asleep. Sleep, which to me is better than alcohol, sex, chocolate and shopping at Target combined, eludes her, and thus me.
I’m at a loss. Cat, 9, started sleeping through the night in her own crib by four months of age and only wakes us if she is severely ill or if there is thunder. Tate, at the age of 7 and a half has slept through the night in her own bed, less than a dozen times.
Now before you judge me as an overly permissive, coddling mom raising a clingy, whiny kid let me note two things: first, she has never screamed loudly about a puzzle or anything else in Target and second, no one who knows her believes me. When we talked to her teacher and school counselor about the issue, they thought we were kidding.
During daylight hours, Tate is fearless. She is the picture of independence. She gets quite snappish if you try to hover or tell her how to do things. She tied her shoes before her older sister did. She dressed herself completely before her older sister did. She used the stove to make eggs, walked alone to the bus stop, and insisted on being dropped off at the door to camp instead of walked inside. Recently, when we need a quart of milk or a single item, she insists that I drive her to the local mini-mart and wait outside while she walks in and purchases the item alone. She thrives on independence.
Except at night. At 8 p.m. all bets are off and she cannot fall asleep without Mommy laying beside her and cuddling her. I am her human teddy bear. Without me, she will lay in bed for HOURS, literally HOURS and not fall asleep. Once asleep, it is only temporary as EVERY night between 1 and 4 a.m. she wanders into the guest room and crawls in beside me. I decamped to the guestroom last year in an effort to give my husband an escape from our sleep-deprived hell. When Tate comes in, it rarely wakes me and if it does, it isn’t for long but Darling Hubby was left tossing and turning.
For the last six months, I have given up on the three-hour long “Go to sleep, Go to sleep, Go to sleep, FOR THE LOVE OF ALL THAT IS HOLY CHILD, GO TO SLEEP” sessions. I just let her go directly to the guest room without passing Go or collecting $200 whereupon I cuddle her for about 30 minutes and she drifts to sleep. Unfortunately, she sleeps in a starfish position, leaving me cling to the edge of the bed for the rest of the night. If I try to sneak in with Darling Hubby after she has drifted off, she wakes up and comes to retrieve me, like the errant well-worn bear that I have become. If I am sick, or just exhausted and send her in with her Dad to cuddle, she wails and shakes as if I have sent her to the gallows. Not only does she need someone to sit with her until she falls asleep, that someone MUST be Mommy. I only get a pass if I am out of town or she is. Only then will she accept a substitute, usually in the form of a Grandma, occasionally in the form of her older sister if all-night t.v. watching is thrown into the deal.
The icing on this crapcake it that Cat now too sleeps in the guest room because otherwise, as she put it, I would be punishing her for being a good sleeper. She needs Mom’s love and attention too and besides, this is saving me a lot of laundry. At this point, I am too tired to put up an argument. The more the merrier ladies, should we invite some friends?
Now as you are judging me, which you almost surely are, let me run down what we have tried in our failed attempts at establishing a normal bedtime routine free of tears and recrimination – traditional Ferberizing, family bed, letting her sleep with her sister, letting her sleep with one of our dogs, letting her sleep with two of our dogs, me sleeping on her floor, giving her melatonin, the occasional Benadryl cocktail (at our doctor’s urging when I hadn’t slept in weeks), a rewards chart, a punishment system, letting her scream it out (her personal best went for six hours and included three rounds of vomiting) and several other things that I have forgotten in my sleep-deprived state. If you told me that standing on my head while wearing a badger costume would work, I would immediately start Googling badger costume outlets. I have no pride. I have no shame. I just want to have my nocturnal hours back to do wacky things like catch up on work and maybe get some sleep myself.
We have consulted over a dozen books, dozens of websites, two pediatricians, her teachers, the school counselor and a therapist. Everyone’s brilliant conclusion? She is a happy, healthy, well-adjusted kid who happens to have sleep issues. She will outgrow it eventually. She is genuinely afraid to sleep for reasons no one knows but her but eventually she will decide its no longer cool or comfortable or necessary to sleep with Mom. Different people have all reached this same conclusion about every six months for the last seven years.
The problem is I am now firmly convinced that she will go from sleeping with me directly into the bed of her first college boyfriend. It’s been more than seven years and I see no light at the end of this tunnel. There is a faint glimmer of hope on the horizon, but Darling Hubby tells me I am setting myself up for disappointment. He thinks that our daughter is like a bad boyfriend, raising my hopes only to dash them on a whim.
This is where my rumination on hope comes in. We took the girls mattress shopping a few weeks ago, thinking that perhaps a new mattress might help. Tate was very excited about the mission and dutifully tested each of the three dozen or so mattresses in the store. We found one that fit her requirements and our budget and were all set to leave when she and Cat spied them – bunk beds.
The set is white, with a twin on top, double on bottom and a trundle for storage or company. And the campaign to win parental hearts and minds commenced. “We SO need these,” they said. “No you don’t,” we countered. “These are the coolest beds ever,” they said. “Being cool is overrated,” we replied. We were holding firm, deflecting their pleas like Wonder Woman deflected bullets until they launched the missile against which we had no defense, “I will start sleeping through the night in my own bed if we get these,” Tate said. “And I will sleep in her room with her to make sure that she does and to help her,” Cat added.
To shorten the recap of the ensuing discussions, Darling Hubby thought it was a bet only a sucker would make. Who on earth would spend twice as much money to get bunk beds on the promise of a child who has so far been unable or unwilling to put herself to sleep without inflicting trauma and herself and her mother? Surely no one is that soft-hearted or soft-headed. Surely, any rational adult would see through this ploy and not fall for it.
To which I reply, in the words of Norman Cousins, “Hope is independent of the apparatus of logic.” Or, as I explained to Darling Hubby while ordering the bunk beds, “If given the choice between betting on my kids or betting against them, no matter what logic dictates, I always want to choose to bet on them. I may end up being wrong but I won’t be sorry.”
The beds are due to be delivered at the end of the month. I hope I like sleeping in them as much as I do the guest room bed.