I have a confession to make. Up until this year, I did not enjoy my children.
That’s right. For the first nine years of my motherhood experience, I didn’t enjoy much of it.
Don’t get me wrong. I love my children. Completely. Utterly. Devastatingly. They are my north, my south, my east, my west. They are, without a doubt, the center of my universe.
It’s just that, until fairly recently, I didn’t enjoy them and my role as their mom.
Some back story is clearly in order here. I was never going to have children. I had resolved early on that I was going to stay single, maybe get a dog and devote myself to my career. Thanks to a boatload of early childhood trauma courtesy of my biological mother and stepfather, the kind that make Augusten Burrough’s childhood look like “Father Knows Best,” I resolved that I would not have children and hence would not risk inflicting the kind of harm on someone else that had been inflicted upon me.
I made it to age 29 with my plan pretty much working, except that I had two dogs instead of one. But I was childless, which to my mind meant that no child would have the affliction of me as a mother. I was certain that I was a carrier of the “Mommy Dearest” gene and hence it was best for all concerned that I did not procreate. I liked children. I loved my friend Karin’s daughter Kate and found her enchanting. But because I loved children, and because I was certain that I was fundamentally defective, I decided not to have kids.
The plan worked great until my dad’s birthday celebration 10 years ago when a combination of ribs and too much Pinot Grigio overcame my better judgment, and my then-fiance and I engaged in the requisite acts that resulted in a positive pregnancy test a few weeks later. Darling Hubby to Be was ecstatic. I was petrified. The first time I threw up was not from morning sickness; it was from terror.
I spent my entire pregnancy in a panic. We had copulated without me being on prenatal vitamins. Certainly I had hurt the baby as a result. I drank Cokes. Certainly I was hurting the baby. We discovered that I was a carrier for cystic fibrosis. Certainly I had doomed her to a difficult life due to my faulty genes. I didn’t follow the “What to Expect” diet regime. Clearly she would be starting life at a deficit.
Darling Hubby likes to tell the story of the first time we ventured into Babies R Us just to get the lay of the land. We had been in there about five minutes when I started to feel hot all over. Then I started to feel dizzy. Then I went into a full-blown panic attack followed by a crying jag right in the middle of the store. If I recall correctly, I ran to the ladies room and vomited. He still looks back on that incident as “sweet” because his interpretation of the events is that I cared so much about being a good mom, that it left me feeling overwhelmed. I look back and remember distinctly the feeling that the Boppies, and sterilizers and bottles and other baby supplies were there merely to highlight my complete ignorance and lack of preparation to be anyone’s mother. How could I be a mother when I didn’t understand how a Diaper Genie worked? The baby could get cholera because I couldn’t figure out the damn thing.
It became worse when Cat was born. From the moment I looked at her, I was fiercely determined to protect her from all harm, real and imagined. My quandary was how to do that when clearly the biggest threat was me. I had no maternal instinct. I had a poor initial role model. I had post-partum depression and a high stress job and no clue at all how to be a good mom to her. I desperately wanted to be one; I just had no idea how to do it. I read dozens of books and articles but failed to find one that covered, “How To Be A Good Mom When You Are Fundamentally Deficient.” My only certainty was that my good enough was nowhere near good enough.
And hence, I would blindly stumble forward, doing my best and then hating myself because my best didn’t measure up to my self-imposed standard. I didn’t breast feed and then took that as Exhibit A in the indictment of myself as Bad Mommy. I went back to work after six weeks of maternity leave. Exhibit B. She had colic. Exhibit C. I gave her cereal in her bottle to help her sleep. Exhibit D. She refused to sleep on her back so we let her sleep on her tummy. Guilty on all counts.
Somehow in the midst of all of this self-loathing, I became pregnant again. My deficiencies didn’t double, they seemed magnified by an order of 10. Now, I was doing everything badly in stereo. Now, my desire to do right by the girls was doubled, but my failures were quadrupled. I was a serial offender now. Two children were afflicted with the life sentence of being my daughters. I would sometimes wish for my own early death so that they would be paroled early.
And hence another seven years went by. I decided that if I couldn’t BE a good mom, I could mimic one. And so I threw myself headlong into trying to do all of the things that good moms did. I read to them every night. I would try to smile when they puked on me. I filled their closets with the cutest clothes I could find and their rooms with educational, safe, age-appropriate toys. I sang Wiggles songs until I wanted to be struck dumb and listened to other kids tunes until I was sure my ears would bleed. I only sent in sandwiches cut in fun shapes. Every waking moment of every day was spent in service to giving the girls the best life possible and protecting them from me.
Every moment I spent with the girls, I spent second-guessing myself. God forbid that I had an actual human reaction like yelling or becoming frustrated. I was sure that those were signs that I was ruining them. Whatever I did, I was sure was wrong, or could have been done better, or should have been done cheerier. I loved them as much as I hated myself.
As you can well imagine, one can only keep up that pace of activity and self-loathing for so long. Eventually, something has to give. First I tried meds, but I felt like a bad mom for needing them. I tried exercise but felt like a bad mom for taking time away from the kids for myself. I tried just crying it out but I felt guilty for needing to cry it out given how fantastic and lovely and spirited my girls were. After about 7 years of white-knuckle parenting, I started therapy.
Fast forward to a recent conversation with my therapist, Todd, a kind, mellow, patient guy. We have spent over two years now talking through my magazine rack of issues and he recently said something that hit me like a thunderbolt. We were talking, yet again, about how I didn’t want my girls to have the same kind of childhood I did. I was telling him (again) about my anxiety-fueled determination to ensure that their experiences did not remotely mirror my own.
And then Todd said something to me that changed my life. “Tanya,” he said, “You are standing on the shore of a placid lake. The sky is blue. The weather is warm. The waves are lapping gently on the shore. All is beautiful at the lake. And you, my friend, are marching up and down the beach scanning the horizon non-stop for a tsunami that you are sure is coming but that will never arrive. You can end the patrol any time. The tsunami isn’t coming.”
I thought about his analogy for a few weeks. I realized that before I was 5, my parents were divorced. Darling Hubby and I will celebrate our 10 year anniversary this fall and he appears to have signed on for a lifetime mission (clearly he has mental health issues of his own). By the time I was nearly 10, Cat’s age, I had lived in at least 7 different addresses and had attended four different schools. The girls have had only two addresses, the most recent for five years and have attended two schools – their preschool and their current school. By the time I was Cat’s age, I had been exposed to cult members, domestic violence, sexual abuse, and mental illness, to name a few. The girls live in a bubble of annual trips to Disney, swim lessons, sleep-overs, and doting grandparents. Their definition of a traumatic event is not having televisions in their bedroom.
In looking at the differences between the worst of my childhood and the worst of theirs, it dawned on me, for the first time, that maybe, just maybe, their lives were this good, not in spite of me, but maybe because of me. Maybe, just maybe, I was able to take the best from my childhood – my Dad and his irreverent humor and focus on education, my Grandma Alice and her unconditional love, my now-Mom, Liz and her willingness to let me make purple cakes and paint windows at Christmas, my friends who told me I was funny and lovable, and others who helped me to survive and thrive- and pass that on to the girls. Maybe I didn’t poison them by exposure to me. Maybe I have strengthened them by it.
And when I realized, at long last, that my children’s lives are not worse for me being in it, and in fact that maybe they are better for it, I was finally able to exhale and enjoy being their mother. I know now that they have stability, they are connected, they are much-loved and they are flourishing.
Will they need a Todd of their own someday? Probably. But, they will also have me, their Mom, with them every step of the way, and now we can actually enjoy the journey together.